A Suffrage History Lesson

Anyone who has studied the woman suffrage movement knows of its unfortunate history of racism; we are again reminded of this by New York Times editor Brent Staples’ Sunday opinion piece, When the Suffrage Movement Sold Out to White Supremacy. In addition to a detailed history of offenses by white suffrage leaders against black suffragists, he offers us welcome but little-known information about black suffragists such as Frances Ellen Watkins Harper, who challenged white reformers to “rid themselves of racism,” and Coralie Franklin Cook, who, despite tremendous regard for Susan B. Anthony felt the movement had “turned its back on women of color.”

There is truth and understandable outrage in these accounts, even viewed through a 21st century lens. But the inescapable fact is that without the tireless efforts of all suffrage leaders for almost a century who knows when the vote would have been won for either black or white women? Certainly this doesn’t excuse racist behavior, but the faults of some white leaders should not completely tarnish the work of thousands, many of whom worked tirelessly for abolition only to see the 15th Amendment give the vote to black men, leaving all women black or white behind.

We cannot change the past, we can only benefit from its study, and there are still many “wrongs to be righted.” How much better it would be to take the lessons learned from these histories and work to eradicate the voter suppression movement that is looming throughout our nation today? There is much work still to be done. Wouldn’t that be the best way to honor these remarkable sung and un-sung participants in the woman suffrage movement, black and white?



4 Responses

  1. linda koenig February 4, 2019 at 12:10 pm | | Reply

    I would encourage you to send these thoughts in letter form to the NYT

  2. Michele LaRue February 4, 2019 at 12:47 pm | | Reply

    Well said . . . it’s for all of us, united, to carry on the fight begun a century ago.

  3. Natalie Naylor February 5, 2019 at 6:52 am | | Reply

    A good history lesson! Yes, voter suppression is one of today’s threats to voting which should be our concern.
    I’m surprised that Staples and Ginia Bellafante in her earlier (Jan. 20) New York Times column on the Stanton-Anthony statue did not mention the Sojourner Truth statue that New York State will be erecting in Ulster County in honor of women’s suffrage. (A second NYS statue in Cold Spring Harbor, Long Island will be of suffragist Rosalie Gardiner Jones.)

  4. John Tepper Marlin February 5, 2019 at 10:37 am | | Reply

    Frances Harper is, I think, better known than Coralie Cook. She was a great organizer, used to go around speaking to local groups. Harper was one of the characters in the suffrage pageant at the Geva Theater in Rochester in 1998.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.